Amber Midthunder on the power of teachers in ‘Carrie’
The actress on her collaboration with Mike Flanagan in the new adaptation of the Stephen King novel, the impact of teachers, and more
Amber Midthunder as Rita Desjardin in Prime Video's 'Carrie'
Prime Video
Words by Daniel Anderson
Stephen King’s Carrie has been adapted for the screen several times, but Mike Flanagan’s new eight-episode Prime Video series gives the story room to explore its characters—and the pressures facing them—with new depth. This iteration brings Carrie White (Summer H. Howell) into the social-media age, where the cruelty of high school extends beyond the hallways and into the digital world, as she navigates friendships with Sue Snell (Siena Agudong), bullying from Chris Hargensen (Alison Thornton), and the complicated adults trying to intervene.
For Amber Midthunder, best known for Legion (2017), Prey (2022), and Novocaine (2025), that adult is Rita Desjardin, a teacher whose fierce instinct to protect Carrie is complicated by the system around her. Rita can’t simply battle her way through every obstacle or force the school to change; she has to navigate administrators, colleagues, students and the limitations of her own authority while trying to do right by a vulnerable teenager. Matthew Lillard’s principal Grayle represents another perspective within that system, while Rita’s relationship with Carrie highlights the deeply human work teachers do behind the scenes.
Midthunder spoke with JoySauce before the premiered on Wednesday about the role teachers play in students’ lives, the educators who made an impact on her, and what it’s like collaborating with Flanagan as a creative.
This interview has been edited for clarity and length.
Daniel Anderson: Rita is a strong and protective character, but she’s also working within a larger system that limits how much she can actually do for Carrie. How did you navigate playing someone who cares deeply but can’t always protect or show up in the way she wants to?
Amber Midthunder: I love this question. Thank you for understanding Miss D. It’s funny. I’ve been paired with Matthew Lillard all weekend. What people take away from our characters is so interesting. Sometimes we’re described as not being very helpful. Sometimes we’re described as being limited but having the best intentions. Sometimes we’re described as heroes. I think that speaks to Mike’s ability and what we’ve done with this iteration.
We’ve expanded the story over eight episodes, so you get to spend so much more time with these characters. There’s so much more complexity and nuance in their emotional journeys that we haven’t gotten to see before.
I think Miss D is a part of that expansion. That was something that I loved when I signed on to this. Getting to see she’s afforded a life outside of school, which in past iterations she’s never really had. She’s never really been just sort of an independent character on her own.
I loved getting to see the life of a young schoolteacher who sort of admits this past that she has, and that she understands where the Chrises and the Sues are coming from, and yet wants everybody to make a better choice.
DA: Were you able to relate to Rita?
AM: Teachers are very close to my heart. My grandmother’s a schoolteacher. I have a friend who is literally a former professional athlete turned high school gym teacher. So I think a lot of these experiences and stories are things that I knew about firsthand.
It’s no secret that teachers are under supported, underpaid, and that the education system needs a lot of help. I’m very happy and proud to be a part of something that, in a subtle and entertaining way, shines a light on that. The biggest thing is that good teachers care really deeply about their students. They could be doing other jobs, they could be making a lot more money, but they’re there because they earnestly care about the well-being of these kids.
DA: One of my favorite interactions is between Carrie and the guidance counselor, Peter Morton, when they connect over books and the library becomes a place of refuge for her. It’s such a beautiful example of the impact a teacher can have on a student. Who was that person for you—whether in school or in the acting industry? Who empowered you?
AM: Absolutely my grandma. I remember doing homework with her after school and always being encouraged to read and pursue education. Visiting her classroom when I was little was so special. Even today, former students will spot her in the grocery store and still call her by her teacher name. If you ask most people, they can immediately name a teacher who impacted them because teachers are special. I’m thankful I got to represent that in this story.
I think our iteration of Carrie gives every type of audience member something to relate to. Whether you’re an original fan of either the book or the De Palma film and you’re coming to this wanting to see all the big set pieces—the prom, the locker room scene, or any of those things—that is delivered. But you also get to experience a brand-new take on our story with a lot of different characters and perspectives, and you understand all those. I think Mike and the cast did a really beautiful job at executing that.
DA: You’re a big reader yourself. If you could give Carrie one book to offer her some comfort or connection, what would it be?
AM: I loved the stack of books she has in the library. Alex Magistro, one of our writers and producers, curated those, and they were all banned books—I love those intentional Easter eggs.
As for what I’d give her: something warm and fuzzy. Carrie just needs a little lighthearted fun. Not that this is lighthearted, but I love The Alchemist as a good first read. I also just finished the A Court of Thorns and Roses series—I’ve officially become an ACOTAR girlie! That might be a bit advanced for Carrie at the moment, but a little fun fantasy never hurt anybody.
DA: If you could put one movie on for Carrie and her classmates to watch, what would you choose?
AM: Oof, as their teacher? That’s a good question. Somebody asked what the first movie we would show Carrie would be, I had picked a slumber party movie. But I do feel like this group needs—I don’t know. I’d probably show them The SpongeBob Movie. I think it’s fun, and there’s also always a lesson about friendship in SpongeBob. That’s what these kids need. They just need to be friends.
DA: In the scene where you put the girls through line drills, how many takes did that actually require, and how much running did you have to do?
AM: Luckily for me, none! But the girls ran quite a bit. Mike Flanagan is incredibly empathetic and thoughtful about what he asks actors to do, both physically and emotionally.
That scene was so much fun to film because I don't have many direct moments with Chris. In that moment, Miss Desjardin goes rogue to take matters into her own hands. It highlights a quality both she and Chris share: neither of them will back down.
DA: As an actor, is there a specific skill or aspect of the craft you're still eager to hone or improve on?
AM: All the time—everything! There’s no better feeling than going to work and feeling challenged. On this production, we had nearly a month of rehearsals, which is unheard of. Being in that intimate space and watching the rest of the cast perform elevated everyone's work. It made you want to stand a little taller, speak with more certainty, and bring your absolute best.
Plus, working with Mike Flanagan is incredible. He is completely transparent—we had all eight episode scripts before signing on, full access to his shot lists, and an app he created to track the shooting schedule. Because he edits his own work, he kept an open-door policy at his edit bay so we could drop in, watch him edit, and ask questions. Those experiences are rare, incredible gifts.
Published on October 12, 2026
Words by Daniel Anderson
Daniel Anderson is a disabled Chinese American adoptee based in Seattle. His freelance writing specialties include K-pop, entertainment, and food. He believes that any restaurant can be a buffet, and the key to success is to take a nap each day. Follow his adventures on Instagram @danzstan.